Standard care. About 1 in 20 metastatic colorectal cancers are microsatellite-instability-high (MSI-high, also reported as dMMR) and respond to checkpoint blockade. The other roughly 95% are microsatellite-stable (MSS): standard care is chemotherapy with a biologic backbone, and checkpoint monotherapy has not worked in MSS disease. For liver-only or lung-only oligometastatic disease, ablation alone is an established local treatment.
Ablation alone. Local treatment of the tumor; any immune effect of ablation alone is not established.
This approach. Image-guided ablation of a tumor, combined in the same session with a multi-agent intratumoral immunotherapy injected into the ablation bed. Pulsed electric field (PEF) ablation, a non-thermal method, is used where the tumor lies against the portal vein, inferior vena cava or hepatic artery; cryoablation is used where the anatomy allows. It is built for MSS disease, the group that standard immunotherapy does not reach. For liver-dominant disease, an intra-arterial option delivers immunotherapy through the hepatic artery. In our clinical observations, lasting immune memory forms against untreated metastatic sites.
The procedure, step by step
- Case review. CT of the abdomen, pelvis and chest, PET, and biomarker reports (MSI/dMMR, KRAS, NRAS, BRAF V600E, HER2, NTRK, RET) are read by the Williams Cancer Institute team.
- Protocol design. The intratumoral combination is chosen from MSI status, mutation profile, immune profile and prior therapy.
- Guidance and ablation. Image-guided percutaneous access. PEF ablation for tumors against the portal vein, inferior vena cava or hepatic artery; cryoablation where the anatomy allows.
- Intratumoral immunotherapy. Through the same access, a multi-agent combination is injected into the ablation bed.
- Intra-arterial option, liver-dominant disease. A catheter is threaded, usually from the groin or wrist, into the hepatic artery, and immune drugs are infused into the liver's own blood supply so that the liver receives a higher concentration than the rest of the body. It can be combined with intratumoral injection of the dominant tumors in the same session.
- Setting and time. About an hour for a needle procedure and about two hours of recovery. Most procedures are outpatient under conscious sedation; general anesthesia or an overnight stay is rarely required.
- Follow-up. Imaging at 6 to 8 weeks. Repeat procedures as indicated; the number of treatments is decided with the patient's physician. The home oncology team is kept informed throughout.
Agents. The injected immunotherapy is a multi-agent combination. The agents and doses are set per patient by the treating physician.
The immune conversion cycle, in clinical terms. Ablation disrupts the tumor and exposes its full antigen repertoire, not a pre-selected subset. The injected immunotherapy then remodels the tumor microenvironment, priming, recruiting and activating immune cells and releasing the brakes on them. Immune-mediated lysis exposes further antigens, which re-prime the response (epitope spreading), producing a broader, polyclonal, systemic response with memory, converting a cold tumor hot. This is WCI’s stated rationale, in Dr. Goodyear’s framing, borne out in our clinical observations.
Rationale. An MSS tumor excludes T cells; without T cells inside the tumor, IV checkpoint drugs have little to act on. WCI's rationale is that breaking the tumor open releases its antigens and danger signals and that the injected agents bring immune cells into a tumor that kept them out. In our clinical observations, ablation re-seeds a T-cell response in MSS colorectal cancer.
Evidence, and its limits. In mice with colorectal tumors and no ablation, anti-CTLA-4 injected into a tumor reached about 14 times the day-7 level of IV dosing in that tumor; the untreated tumor received no more than with IV dosing, and half the dose reached the blood within an hour [1]. That is mouse data; it does not test ablation or show a distant-site effect. For the intra-arterial route, the established hepatic arterial infusion data are for chemotherapy (floxuridine pump series); the intra-arterial immunotherapy data are early and mostly in primary liver cancer, not colorectal, and no randomized trial of intra-arterial versus IV immunotherapy in colorectal liver metastases has completed. Chemotherapy results do not transfer to immunotherapy. There is no published WCI series in colorectal cancer and no randomized trial of this combination. Sources
- Meyblum L, et al. J Immunother Cancer 2023. PMID 37949616. DOI 10.1136/jitc-2023-007433.